
My battle of wits with a domain taster
By Noah (asides, domains, tips)
Most people that know me know that I’m a bit domain-crazy. Any half-good idea that I have usually results in a domain name purchase–mostly as a “just in case” I decide to actually develop it. Despite the fact that this is a self-enabling and productivity damaging practice, I still partake in it. However, I have significantly limited myself in terms of what I let myself purchase (the next step was locking my laptop in a trunk and burying it in the back yard).
With that being said, a business parter and I have had our eyes on a particular domain name that is perfect for a future expansion of our current project, IndyDads.com. The domain name we wanted was DadNation.com. I’ll let your capable mind explore exactly what our future idea is with this domain instead of writing about it here. As luck would have it, the domain was up for expiration last month and I was excited at the prospect of snagging it. This is where I ran into trouble.
I was all ready to go. I had my domain name backorder set through GoDaddy and was just waiting for the good news. Now, I understand a thing or two about how competitive the domain name aftermarket can be and that for most good domains, it’s difficult and expensive to snap up expiring names. However, I figured with the relatively low demand for this domain, I would have no problem getting it. I knew I was in trouble when I received my very first email from a domain taster.
Because I had already registered DadNation.org, the domain taster’s automated system had managed to snap up the dot com AND generate a marketing email to me explaining that I could acquire the dot com easily by purchasing it through their company. The asking price? $997!
Ouch! No way. Perhaps if I was some big company that just had to have the domain, $997 wouldn’t seem like so much. But, for a side-project that is mostly a labor of love, that is out of the question.
So, I figured I had lost the domain for good. But, the way the email was written, I figured it was a form letter and not an actual human sending me the message. Two days later, I received another email that was similar, but contained a slightly more urgent call to action. I did some research on domain tasters and confirmed that they indeed only had 5 days to return their domains for a refund. Also, based on what I had read, often times domain tasters base the value of a domain off of the traffic hitting the domain. So, I was careful to neither visit the domain DadNation.com or respond to any of the emails.
I held my breath for 2 more days (not literally).
Then, on August 3rd, I received an email from GoDaddy alerting me that the name servers had changed to GoDaddy name servers! Then, another email telling me my backorder had been successful! It worked! The domain taster returned the domain after getting nothing out of me and I was able to register it for the normal price.
Having lost good domains in the past to a variety of frustrating reasons, it was nice to actually win one (and without spending a small fortune). While I’m sure the situation would change depending on the exact domain name in question, but my parting advice is that your best weapon against a domain taster is patience and silence (and an active backorder on the domain).
Projects

LifeStream
- September 2nd
- 9:00 pm How I automatically email my family photos every day - http://bit.ly/b6rlp4
- 6:25 pm RT @WestCoastTacos: So today at #IUPUI, the Hot Dog Lady called the Health Department on us.Good thing we follow all rules.We passed the surprise inspection!
- 6:14 pm Devs VS Marketing! RT @chris_c_lucas: Ping Pong Table @Formstack office is not even 5 minutes old and #Trashtalk has already started. Nice!
- 2:19 pm Hook in to the power of FlowTown with @Formstack WebHooks http://bit.ly/9175we
- 1:01 pm Email your family flickr photos automatically - http://noahcoffey.com/L4
- 1:01 pm Email your family flickr photos automatically
- 1:43 am RT @taptivate: We still have four more iPhone 4's to give away! Be sure to enter and tell all of your friends: http://bit.ly/bP6A7X
- September 1st
- 10:26 pm

- 7:53 pm RT @gopsig: Startup looking for funding or co-founder? Programmer/designer looking to join a startup? Come pitch at @thecombineorg http://ow.ly/2y7OG
- 6:44 pm HugeTweets.com, I release you back to the wild. Godspeed.
View Comments
Hi Noah,
I work for Network Solutions. Hopefully with the new policy passed by ICANN in June this practice will come to an end by hitting tasters with a non refundable charge during the 5-day period. Thanks for sharing your story, it will be a good one for us to share with our customers as well. – Shashi Bellamkonda smedia@networksolutions.com
heheh i am not a domain taster but a bit domain crazy just like you ! its a nice read ,looks like you were extremely lucky, something like this happened to me a year ago !
Leave a reply